I think he deserves the hate in the sense that sanemi and obanai are justified in disliking him for his behaviour, but giyuu is also a traumatized kid who shouldn't really be blamed for pushing people away after his best (?) friend died saving him.

Giyuu's punishment is multifaceted, stemming from both his personal decisions and the expectations placed upon him as a hashira.

Flashbacks reveal giyu's survivor's guilt from the final selection exam and the loss of his older sister.

Recommended for you

I don’t recommend reading tbh since this will definitely make you think of the hashira differently but note that this is unofficial and not real.

Giyu tomioka, the pillar of water of the demon slayer corps, is a intriguing figure whose choices often reflect the nuanced nature of punishment.

Opponents of giyu's punishment vehemently denounce its severity, asserting that it was an excessive and unfair response to a minor infraction.

Giyuu s punishment controversy unfair or justified.

Since giyuu himself doesn’t really try to communicate, they get the impression that giyuu thinks they are not worth his time.

— by examining giyuu’s character through the lens of his punishment, we can gain a deeper understanding of the complexities of heroism and the sacrifices made in the battle.

There's a fanmade manga about giyu's punishment for letting tanjiro live, i'll just say that they do some really messed up stuff to giyu in that manga

Kimetsu no yaiba dj.

Giyu's refusal to participate in training is linked to unresolved feelings of guilt and grief over sabito's death.

One significant moment that defines his punishment is his encounter with tanjiro kamado.

They maintain that giyu's actions were justified given the extraordinary circumstances and that the punishment was disproportionate to the alleged offense.

Giyuu's punishment is often explored in the context of the choices he makes, particularly regarding his relationships with other characters and the moral dilemmas he faces.

You may also like

The giyuu punishment a cruel ritual or a form of discipline.

Now that’s obviously false but giyuu has not tried to clarify his stance with them, which results in many of the pillars to have a negative view on him.